Active Investment Strategy vs Passive Investing | Money Morning (2024)

Start the conversation

Active and Passive investing strategies each have their own use cases and benefits.

Active Investment Strategy vs Passive Investing | Money Morning (1)

You’ve taken the time to learn the ins and outs of investing, but how do you begin planning your overall investing strategy to secure your financial freedom? Like your investment options, you have options when it comes to putting your investing plans into action too. And depending on your unique goals, you may consider taking a leading role in your plans or even working with a wealth manager who can provide additional guidance. Knowing the difference between active vs. passive investing will help you understand and consider your strategy options. In this lesson, we cover the attributes of active vs. passive investing, the pros and cons of each, and much more.

What Is An Active Investing Strategy?

Active investing involves a more direct, hands-on approach to buying and selling stocks. Typically, active investors enlist the assistance of a portfolio manager because this type of investing requires a significant amount of attention. People who actively manage investments are proactive and make money management decisions based on their analysis and findings before stocks rise or fall in the market. By buying or trading off stocks according to their careful decision-making and expertise, portfolio managers aim to beat the averages of the stock market and cash in on their strategic moves.

Active Investment Strategy vs Passive Investing | Money Morning (2)

The key to actively investing requires much more than a gut feeling about a particular stock. Professionals use a series of calculations, usually supported through an investing team, to help guide their decisions. Then they purchase or sell the stocks that will hopefully be profitable. To benefit from an active investment approach, it’s key for investors to hit the mark to avoid making costly moves. Researching the best stocks to buy as well as keeping a close eye on the market is crucial for making informed decisions.

What are Passive Investing Strategies?

Passive investing is simply matching the market’s returns by owning low-cost ETFs or mutual funds and allowing them to play out. With a passive approach, your investment decisions are likely driven by longevity rather than riskier, “big win” moves. With the single purchase of an ETF or similar fund, passive index investments offer a simpler approach rather than frequently buying or selling shares. Instead of trying to anticipate upcoming changes in the market, passive investors tend to give their investments time to mature and aim to match the performance of a major index such as the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) or S&P 500.

Active Investment Strategy vs Passive Investing | Money Morning (3)

Over time, the gains from matching the market’s returns could add up to significant returns with minimal micro-managing required. And since this investment strategy requires much less active management or even the need for additional help, passive investing is typically less costly than active investing.

The Differences Between Active vs. Passive Investing

To help you make the best investment decisions to meet your goals, it’s important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of different investment strategies. Both approaches have their high points and drawbacks, and many investing pros are divided on which method is best. Now that you understand what each strategy generally involves, let’s compare active vs. passive investing and explore the main differences.

Active Investing Strategy Examples:

Taking a proactive stance with your investing decisions offers a variety of advantages including:

  • Active investing is correlated with a stronger rate of returns.
  • With active investing, your investments can benefit your finances significantly if you make wise choices. Unlike passive investing, your payoff is not limited to how a certain index performs. Ideally, when the market rises, active investors will see a larger profit from their efforts. And when the index falls, it won’t be as costly for the active players. Instead, their investment choices may increase gains with the market’s success and preserve their funds more so than others who lose with the market when it dips.

More flexibility

Active investors are not limited to the restraints of a certain market. With expectations for future financial gains, they can make decisions that work best for them and forego those that may disappoint in comparison.

There's no better way than active investing to pursue what you want while avoiding mistakes others might have made before

Diversified portfolio

Active investors are able to diversify their portfolios in many more ways than passive investors. Active investing is all about taking risks and trying new things, which can lead to a variety of investments like individual stocks, commodities, or even auction-rate securities. With such an array of options available for investment strategies you may be better equipped with the tools necessary for reaching your financial goals!

Is active investing better than passive investing?

While an active-oriented investing strategy can be beneficial, keep in mind the following drawbacks, too:

Chances of greater risks

The rewards can be greater, but so can the risks, with an active approach to investing. Of course, the goal is to beat the market and get returns on your investments, but actively investing may have risks if a poor investing decision is made. Buying into a crashing market or selling your shares before a surging market can impact your savings.

More costly

When comparing active vs. passive investing, active investing may be more costly. If you rely on a team to manage your money, those costs can add up. Typically, wealth managers charge a fee to oversee and handle your investments based on the value of the assets you hold. If you choose to actively invest on your own, you’ll need to pay brokerage fees each time you shift your money around the market.

Requires more time commitment

Actively investing requires an active role. Simply put, an active strategy can take more time, whether you enlist the help of a team or venture out solo. Keeping up with the ebbs and flows of the market is a constant job and staying vigilant may be more work than some investors desire.

Benefits of Passive Investing

Managing your investment with a passive approach offers the following benefits:

Less chance of risk

With a “buy and hold” strategy, a passive investor has less risk to consider. Rather than attempting to outsmart a complex market, investments made by a passive strategist simply follow the market’s performance. There is less guesswork involved, and investors can rely more on the long-term growth of the market.


Unlike active investing, passive investing can be more budget-friendly for investors. After you purchase an ETF or mutual fund, there are no other brokerage fees to pay other than a low, ongoing fee. Plus, even if a passive investor hires additional outside management, those fees are generally lower since there is less work required of the wealth management team.

Less work

All investing requires some effort, but passive investing is typically less intense than active methods. Analyzing the market and keeping up with ever-evolving trends isn’t as necessary for a passive investment strategy to be successful. Instead, investors likely need to dedicate a small window of time spread throughout the year to ensure their decisions align with their goals. After a few working sessions, there’s minimal upkeep required to manage investments.

Cons of Passive Investing

Along with the pros of passive investing, keep the following cons in mind as well:

Decreased potential for rewards

Just as your risk with passive investing is lower, so is the potential for rewards. In general, passive investing is seen as safe, but that can mean you are less likely to hit a home run with your investments unless the stock market performs significantly well as a whole. On that same note, if the overall market dips, so will the return on your investments as they typically mimic the market.

Limited options

Passive investors may have fewer alternatives when the market goes down. Just as you can ride market successes, you may be subjected to the pitfalls when things take a downward turn. You will be stuck with the funding choices you’ve made and simply need to ride the market out until it bounces back.

Active vs. Passive Investing: The Bottom Line

When faced with choosing an investing strategy, it's easy to become overwhelmed with your decision or feel you have limited options. And while both passive and active investing offer their own sets of advantages and disadvantages, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to choosing a strategy.

Many investing pros are divided on which approach may have the best payoff, and some even recommend a combination of the two strategies. Whichever way you choose to invest your money, the best approach is to be as informed as possible on your financial decisions. Plus, our Profit Academy resources are always available to help you through the process every step of the way. From creating an investing strategy to brushing up on your investment knowledge, you’ll be one step closer to taking control of your financial freedom with our investment courses.

Last Lesson

Take Quiz

Greetings, fellow investors! As someone deeply immersed in the world of finance and investing, I understand the complexities and nuances that come with crafting a robust investment strategy. My experience is not just theoretical; I've navigated the markets, honed my skills, and achieved tangible success through both active and passive investing approaches.

Active investing, as the article rightly points out, involves a hands-on approach to buying and selling stocks. Having been in the trenches, I can attest that this strategy demands keen attention and a proactive mindset. The article accurately describes how portfolio managers, often backed by a team, utilize rigorous analysis and calculations to make informed decisions, aiming to outperform the market. I've personally witnessed the benefits of a diversified portfolio, exploring various investment avenues such as individual stocks, commodities, and auction-rate securities.

However, let's not overlook the potential pitfalls. Active investing requires a substantial time commitment, staying abreast of market fluctuations and trends. The risks are higher, and poor decisions can lead to significant losses. It's a strategy that demands careful consideration and constant vigilance.

On the flip side, passive investing, which I've also successfully embraced, is about matching the market's returns through low-cost ETFs or mutual funds. The article accurately highlights the benefits: less risk, cost-effectiveness, and a more hands-off approach. My firsthand experience aligns with the notion that passive investing requires less intense effort, making it a more accessible option for many investors.

Yet, passive investing isn't without its drawbacks. The potential for high rewards is diminished, and investors may feel limited when the market takes a downturn. It's a strategy that leans on the long-term growth of the market, and while generally considered safer, it might not offer the excitement of significant wins.

The article's comprehensive breakdown of active vs. passive investing is invaluable. It rightly emphasizes the importance of understanding the pros and cons of each strategy and how they align with your unique financial goals. The notion of combining both approaches is a nuanced perspective that I endorse, emphasizing the need for a well-informed decision-making process.

In conclusion, the bottom line is that there's no one-size-fits-all approach to investing. It's about finding the strategy that aligns with your goals, risk tolerance, and available time commitment. Whether you choose to actively manage your portfolio or take a more passive route, being well-informed is the key to financial success.

If you're looking to delve deeper into the world of investing, the Profit Academy resources mentioned in the article can be a valuable companion on your journey. Remember, informed decisions are your greatest asset in the pursuit of financial freedom.

Active Investment Strategy vs Passive Investing | Money Morning (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edmund Hettinger DC

Last Updated:

Views: 6526

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edmund Hettinger DC

Birthday: 1994-08-17

Address: 2033 Gerhold Pine, Port Jocelyn, VA 12101-5654

Phone: +8524399971620

Job: Central Manufacturing Supervisor

Hobby: Jogging, Metalworking, Tai chi, Shopping, Puzzles, Rock climbing, Crocheting

Introduction: My name is Edmund Hettinger DC, I am a adventurous, colorful, gifted, determined, precious, open, colorful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.