Easy Peanut Butter Fairy Bread Recipe - Sugar & Cloth (2024)

Sharing our version of fairy bread with a recipe that’s just as fun and easy to make as it looks!

You know us well enough by now to know that we’re sold on anything called fairy bread.

Admittedly, the name can, however, scare off husbands and teenagers.

And by scaring off, we mean they may suffer a little hazing once they unpack their lunch to find a rainbow treat.

Everyone else will love it though, including you, since this is the easiest sandwich ever!

We are sharing our favorite fairy bread recipe that is bound to be a conversation starter…

What is Fairy Bread?

Fairy bread is a popular snack from Australia and New Zealand that is commonly served at birthday parties.

The traditional fairy bread recipe uses just three ingredients: bread, butter, and sprinkles. This buttered bread dish is typically cut in different shapes.

The origin of its name is unknown.

Some people speculate that it came from the poem “Fairy Bread” by Robert Louis Stevenson in his “A Child’s Garden of Verses,” published in 1885.

But we really think the rainbow sprinkles are the reason why for its name!

Alternatively, here are a few sweet breakfast recipes that we recommend.

Ingredients and Tools Needed to Make My Version of Fairy Bread

And as much as we love butter, we put our own twist on an Australian food favorite.

So instead of white bread spread with butter, we opted to make an actual sandwich.

Though it may be sacrilegious to change up Australian fairy bread, who doesn’t love a peanut butter sandwich?!?

Slices of bread with crust off

Peanut butter or Nutella

Honey

Sprinkles

Cookie cutter

How to Make Peanut Butter Fairy Bread Sandwich

Step 1 – To make my version, spread peanut butter on the bottom slice.

Step 2 – Add a dash of honey to the bottom slice.

Step 3 – Dust in a layer of sprinkles.

Step 4 – Then place a cookie cutter down on the top slice of bread to get your desired cutout shape. Press down firmly and remove the cutout.

Step 5 – Sandwich the cut slice on top of the bottom slice.

More Fun Snack and Lunch Ideas

This peanut butter fairy bread sandwich is a cute way to surprise someone with a DIY lunch note card, don’t you think? You could even serve them as finger foods for a party!

I’m basically partial to anything that includes rainbow sprinkles, and for our complete baked goods recipe, you can check out this post.

For more fun and colorful recipes, check out a few of our favorites from the archives —

• All Natural Unicorn Toast — A fun recipe with sweet and savory garnishes
• Sugar Cookie Funfetti Cake — It’s a cookie and cookie with loads and loads of sprinkles!
• Healthy Nut Free Lunches (that are Kid-Approved) — Quick and easy bagel pizzas, SunButter banana “quesadillas,” and pancake sandwiches…
• White Chocolate Funfetti Popcorn — We seriously weren’t lying when we said we loved sprinkles.

Don’t forget to share your fairy bread with us onInstagramusing the hashtag#sugarandclothloves. We always love seeing all of your creations! Looking for more quick and delicious recipes? You can find them allright here,with a fewdessertsto go along with them!